Did Jesus Perform Any Signs? If He Did Then How Many?


Bassam Zawadi

There is a contradiction in the Bible. In one verse, we read that Jesus said that no sign will be given to his generation:

Mark 8:11-13

11The Pharisees came and began to question Jesus. To test him, they asked him for a sign (semeion) from heaven. 12He sighed deeply and said, "Why does this generation ask for a miraculous sign (semeion)? I tell you the truth, no sign (semeion) will be given to it." 13Then he left them, got back into the boat and crossed to the other side. 

However, another place says that his generation would be given the sign of Jonah:

Matthew 12:38-39

38Then some of the Pharisees and teachers of the law said to him, "Teacher, we want to see a miraculous sign (semeion) from you." 39He answered, "A wicked and adulterous generation asks for a miraculous sign (semeion)! But none will be given it except the sign (semeion) of the prophet Jonah. 

Some Christians might try to say that Jesus meant that they would not receive a sign from heaven in Mark 8; however, Jesus clarified that they would not receive any semeion and did not specify which kind. Jesus said no semeion would be given to his generation. However, we don't see this in Matthew. 

Source of information:

http://www.blueletterbible.org/tmp_dir/c/1138988400-5563.html#38 (concordance for Matthew 12:38)

http://www.blueletterbible.org/tmp_dir/c/1138988426-704.html#39 (concordance for Matthew 12:39)

http://www.blueletterbible.org/tmp_dir/c/1138988338-6435.html#11 (concordance for Mark 8:11)

http://www.blueletterbible.org/tmp_dir/c/1138988057-1616.html#12 (concordance for Mark 8:12) 

Obviously, when Jesus was talking about giving the people the 'Sign of Jonah', he was referring to his alleged resurrection. (What would be miraculous about him dying and being buried?)

Another question arises regarding all of Jesus' other miracles, such as healing the blind and the leper, resurrecting the dead, and feeding thousands with little food. Aren't all of these miracles considered signs?

Either there is a discrepancy between Jesus saying that he will give NO SIGN to the Jews except the sign of Jonah and him doing other miracles such as healing the blind and raising the dead. 

The other option is Christians stating that Jesus' healing of the blind and his raising of the dead were not miracles or signs of his Prophethood. But that makes no sense. If they were not signs, then why would Jesus perform these miracles?

Someone might argue that Jesus meant to say that he would give no sign afterward from that particular point in time. However, this could easily be refuted by simply reading after that passage and seeing passages such as Mark 8:22-26, which show that Jesus healed a blind man, or Mark 9:14-onwards, which shows Jesus performing exorcism on a boy.

Questions That Christians Need to Answer


1) Why did Jesus say that no sign would be given to his generation in Mark 8:11-13 but that one sign would be given in Matthew 12:38-39? Weren't Mark's audience misled by Mark's Gospel and understood that Jesus told the Jews that he would provide them with no sign?

2) If you were successful at harmonizing the difficulty above, then how do you explain the fact that Jesus told the Jews that he would only give them ONE SIGN, and that is the sign of Jonah? Does this not contradict the fact that he did perform other signs, such as healing the blind and feeding thousands with a small amount of food?



Return to Is the Bible the Word of God? 

Return to Homepage

HomeWhat's new?ChristianityRefutations Contact Me